1463Cubbins Paratrooper wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2023 10:33 amI think the attendance was announced on the radio at just over 1,400, though stand to be corrected. My attention was elsewhere at the time.
Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
-
saltcellar
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 2867
- Joined: Mon Jun 22, 2009 7:44 pm
- Contact:
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
-
Suffolk Blue
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3810
- Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 6:09 pm
- Contact:
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
Don’t see any of this as finger pointing Hoss. It’s just one of those debates that we have from time to time. And everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Certain players just seem to polarise those views. Garner is clearly one.
I do agree that Garner has probably not turned out to be the player the we all (inc PW) perhaps we’re led to believe. And if he wanted to leave that would be a different matter. Or if someone came in with a decent offer then ok. In the absence of those things happening however I’d be very surprised if we proactively tried to ship him out.
Cox started the debate about Squad versus Team at the weekend. My guess is that football managers tend to look at other managers a little differently to the way supporters do. What I think Paul Cox was alluding to was that what he sees in PW is a very good squad builder. That is also probably the way we should look at Pete Wilds decisions. It would explain why he persists with players when some of us wouldn’t. He is forever trying to get his players to fit in to a 25 man not an 11 man system.
If Garner can’t be a 20 goal a season striker then PW will try and find something that he can be until all options are exhausted.
I do agree that Garner has probably not turned out to be the player the we all (inc PW) perhaps we’re led to believe. And if he wanted to leave that would be a different matter. Or if someone came in with a decent offer then ok. In the absence of those things happening however I’d be very surprised if we proactively tried to ship him out.
Cox started the debate about Squad versus Team at the weekend. My guess is that football managers tend to look at other managers a little differently to the way supporters do. What I think Paul Cox was alluding to was that what he sees in PW is a very good squad builder. That is also probably the way we should look at Pete Wilds decisions. It would explain why he persists with players when some of us wouldn’t. He is forever trying to get his players to fit in to a 25 man not an 11 man system.
If Garner can’t be a 20 goal a season striker then PW will try and find something that he can be until all options are exhausted.
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
I disagree that Garner has been 'very poor'.
What do his main critics see his role as in the team?
What do his main critics see his role as in the team?
THE NORTHERN WAY
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
I would call him an attacking midfielder. I agree that he has not set the world on fire and he is never been the star player in a match, but in some games I have seen he has worked hard and set up others, a contribution that may go unnoticed. He carries the burden of the 'record fee' tag. If he had just been an 'ordinary' signing (if there is such a thing), perhaps supporters wouldn't be looking for star quality.
- BarrowLad71
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 570
- Joined: Sun Apr 03, 2022 6:45 pm
- Contact:
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
He’s not a goal scorer. He’s not in the side to be one and I don’t personally expect him to be one. But what he is, is a very good technical player who links play well and holds the ball well. Get behind him
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
In this day and age of almost universal 'undisclosed fees' I still find it hard to believe that we have paid a record fee for anybody. Who actually disclosed this as a 'record' or is it just some off the cuff remark which has gathered momentum. Believe it or not but footballers are human and he could well as others have suggested be struggling to live up to the tag.Forgeetting the fee I wouldn't have thought we would give a three year contract to somebody without thorough accreditation from several sources.
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
He’s a forward, if he’s dropping deeper to bring others into play then he’s not in the box to get on the end of crosses or through balls.
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.
-
Suffolk Blue
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3810
- Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 6:09 pm
- Contact:
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
That's true. But whenever I've seen him he's been better as a creator than a finisher. That may be by default rather than design though.
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
Suffolk Blue wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2023 5:17 pmThat's true. But whenever I've seen him he's been better as a creator than a finisher. That may be by default rather than design though.
You are the most analytical poster on here and yet you’re overlooking what the main role of a striker is.
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.
-
Main Stand SeasonTct
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3324
- Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2017 5:05 pm
- Contact:
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
Very true. Pete Wild alluded to it on a radio interview earlier in the season when talking about Garner. He said he has the ability to pick a pass and break down a tight defence. This to me said that PW sees him more of a creator than a finisher and the way he appears to be being used and asked to play backs that up IMOSuffolk Blue wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2023 5:17 pmThat's true. But whenever I've seen him he's been better as a creator than a finisher. That may be by default rather than design though.
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
Great run out for the young lads. Second half looked much better. We need to remember that Etaluku is 20,Bray and Bellis are 21 and Reeve is only 19 I thought they all played really well. 

Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
Probably going to get slated but I would have brought Quigley back.
He has been shipped out to Eastleigh and now scoring goals again so would have cost us nothing.
He has been shipped out to Eastleigh and now scoring goals again so would have cost us nothing.
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
Welcome to the forum Claire. Yes they all came into the side and did well. I’ll add Malakai Reeve who came on for the second half and didn’t look out of place at all.
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
What am I missing here? He’s supposed to be on the end of crosses, not providing them. Maybe this is why we are in with the lowest goal scorers in the league!! Thankfully we’ve been tight in defence and a keeper playing out of his skin week in week out.Main Stand SeasonTct wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2023 6:38 pmVery true. Pete Wild alluded to it on a radio interview earlier in the season when talking about Garner. He said he has the ability to pick a pass and break down a tight defence. This to me said that PW sees him more of a creator than a finisher and the way he appears to be being used and asked to play backs that up IMOSuffolk Blue wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2023 5:17 pm
That's true. But whenever I've seen him he's been better as a creator than a finisher. That may be by default rather than design though.
Please expand on this. We have creative players all over the side, we need strikers to put it in the net!
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.
-
behind the goals
- Gold Member
- Posts: 2305
- Joined: Fri Jan 24, 2014 9:44 pm
- Contact:
Re: Barrow v Liverpool U21s, match thread
Scott Quigley played 18 games for Eastleigh this season(16 full 90 mins) and scored 6 goals, scored twice in 2 games v Oxford City 2-2 and in a 3-2 defeat v Maidenhead got more bookings 7 in total, if brought back would you start him or just another squad player.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: colyates, MisterPleasant and 22 guests