Holker Street Development

For all things Barrow AFC. Keep discussions civil and fair, we're all Barrow aren't we!
olbarrafancumbak
Platinum Member
Posts: 2527
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:41 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by olbarrafancumbak » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:03 pm

Jonty wrote:I'm thinking about a Plan B for ground development. Everything would need to be to league requirements of course.

- Refurbish existing floodlights- or replace one by one so they are all like the newer one. Do you think our floodlights can be saved? Has anyone actually conducted a structual assesment of the pylons with a view to saving them? The four main legs of each look to be in reasonable condition and so do most of the cross members. The newer pylon is only about 5 years old. On the other three, The ladders and the cages themselves are what need the work. Maybe a local fabrication / Engineering firm could get onboard and strike a deal with the club- (Main Shirt Sponsorship maybe?) in return for refurbishment over the next season.

There is an element of nostalgia with the flood lights but are they worth keeping? I doubt it would be cost effective in the long run

- "Goal Post style" structure for HS End Roof- no need to knock down and replace existing terrace- A single span goalpost style framework from each corner would support the entire roof, unobstructed. Re build back wall street side. This is the cheapest stadium roof design.

Im not entirely sure what you mean by "goal post style" Though the issue regarding the suitability of the ground under HS shouldnt really be an issue with so many lightweight materials out there. But the shelf life of concrete is only something like 50 yrs before it degenerates, so it would need replacing anyway! "you cant polish a turd" I think the expression is

- replace missing Popside terrace Steps- backdown to pitch side- as it was.

Forgive my ignorance, what happened to the steps, where they removed or were they never laid? I know it was to do with speedway

- Build Cross Bar 2, moving changerooms into Popside/ Crossbar corner, block existing tunnel and this becomes the away end. Include revenue making facilities- ie conference rooms, BAFC gym, BAFC health spa, BAFC business lets, etc- all revenues coming to us, . Full hospitality suites upstairs. - Green thinking - solar panels on Crossbar roof, (small revenue stream for club). Study centre, etc.

- new playing surface.

Does it need one or do you mean it needs planing? it used to be one of the best pitches in non league, not sure why it looks so dippy, ground movement?

purchase Bluebirdclub, turn it into a successful matchday revenue stream, function suite.

- Extend Main Stand to full length of pitch. Additional floodlighing along roof edge-(like Craven Park main stand)

newturnstyle systems

any QS out there?- How much for all that then?

Any aspiring new board members- Never mind the sarnies- HS Development is your strategic focus.- We need to explore all alternatives.

Plan B views? - is this doable?, would it be more cost effective than the total rebuild shown on the feasibility study?? Funded by sponsorships of everything and whatever sports grants we can secure.
Ive said for a long time now that we should try and get involved in a "community scheme" utilising the collages and apprentice's to design/build/fabricate/manage etc etc. They get to be involved in something local, get qualifications, probably funding? and we get a newer ground, designed and built by locals :D Theres probably a loophole somewhere where it could receive funding?

Lancaster Branch
BarrowAFC Veteran
Posts: 5509
Joined: Sun Jun 15, 2008 10:15 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Lancaster Branch » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:04 pm

Jonty wrote:I'm thinking about a Plan B for ground development.

[insert uncosted wishlist]

any QS out there?- How much for all that then?

Plan B views? - is this doable?, would it be more cost effective than the total rebuild shown on the feasibility study?? Funded by sponsorships of everything and whatever sports grants we can secure.
So, your 'plan' consists of lots of things you don't know the cost of, funded by a sponsorship and grants warchest that you don't know the size of.

As plans go, there's only one man who's ever come up with anything better.

Image

User avatar
Jonty
BarrowAFC Veteran
Posts: 11180
Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 11:01 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Jonty » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:14 pm

barrowscuba wrote:Don't you think your plan b would have already been actioned if it was so simple? You don't appear to appreciate how much work costs and the fact that the club don't have enough money to run on a day to day basis never mind paying to upgrade the ground to a reasonable standard.

I believe that Chas Kendall paid around £10k a year for shirt sponsorship. That might buy a few bulbs, not three new floodlight pylons.

The goalpost style roof ...what do you plan on securing the goalposts to? It's been well documented in the past that new foundations would be required for any new terracing/stand/roofing at the Holker Street End and that the foundations have been costed at £250K alone.

Purchase Bluebird Club & build Crossbar 2 ...... where's the money coming from.

Fundamental flaws in all your ideas sorry. It all boils down to cold hard cash and we dont have any.
Money is the issue- of course I know that- do you think I don't appreciate that?, This is just about alternatives to the results of the feasibility study that may be possibly more cost effective. You have totally failed to see that.
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.

olbarrafancumbak
Platinum Member
Posts: 2527
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:41 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by olbarrafancumbak » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:18 pm

Jonty wrote:
barrowscuba wrote:Don't you think your plan b would have already been actioned if it was so simple? You don't appear to appreciate how much work costs and the fact that the club don't have enough money to run on a day to day basis never mind paying to upgrade the ground to a reasonable standard.

I believe that Chas Kendall paid around £10k a year for shirt sponsorship. That might buy a few bulbs, not three new floodlight pylons.

The goalpost style roof ...what do you plan on securing the goalposts to? It's been well documented in the past that new foundations would be required for any new terracing/stand/roofing at the Holker Street End and that the foundations have been costed at £250K alone.

Purchase Bluebird Club & build Crossbar 2 ...... where's the money coming from.

Fundamental flaws in all your ideas sorry. It all boils down to cold hard cash and we dont have any.
Money is the issue- of course I know that- do you think I don't appreciate that?, This is just about alternatives to the results of the feasibility study that may be possibly more cost effective. You have totally failed to see that.
I think refurbishing would only be "papering over the cracks" and would probably be false economy!

User avatar
Jonty
BarrowAFC Veteran
Posts: 11180
Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 11:01 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Jonty » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:20 pm

LB- No I don't know the cost of these things, but what would be the cost of the ground development through the feasibility - Has anyone queried that and what would fund that? and have we looked at alternatives?
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.

User avatar
Andy
Gold Member
Posts: 1729
Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 4:40 pm
Location: Barrow
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Andy » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:25 pm

The people who want top build around Holker Street would put in an amount of money that would immediately open up lots of grants through matched funding or semi matched funding. That's how read the funding issue.
It is hard enough to remember my opinions, without also remembering my reasons for them!
Friedrich Nietzsche

Lancaster Branch
BarrowAFC Veteran
Posts: 5509
Joined: Sun Jun 15, 2008 10:15 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Lancaster Branch » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:27 pm

The new development will be paid for by a communal rummage down the back of all sofas in the Furness area.

The alternative is a new ground built out of matchsticks to be placed in Walney Channel. It will be called 'Keen Island'.


Seriously though, do you REALLY. Think that funding and alternatives haven't been considered? Really?

User avatar
Jonty
BarrowAFC Veteran
Posts: 11180
Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 11:01 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Jonty » Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:37 pm

Lancaster Branch wrote:The new development will be paid for by a communal rummage down the back of all sofas in the Furness area.

The alternative is a new ground built out of matchsticks to be placed in Walney Channel. It will be called 'Keen Island'.


Seriously though, do you REALLY. Think that funding and alternatives haven't been considered? Really?
Well there you go!- that's as much about what we know about funding as anything. I shall search the back of my sofa! You are right though- We've seen an outline plan of a redeveloped HS but no detail. Yes I know-we are still waiting.
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.

User avatar
Steelworks End
BarrowAFC Veteran
Posts: 5959
Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 6:03 pm
Location: Twickenham
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Steelworks End » Mon Jan 23, 2012 12:36 pm

olbarrafancumbak wrote:
Jonty wrote:- replace missing Popside terrace Steps- backdown to pitch side- as it was.

Forgive my ignorance, what happened to the steps, where they removed or were they never laid? I know it was to do with speedway
The front few rows (I can't remember how many) of the Popular Side terrace were removed at the time the speedway track was laid in the early 1970s, and a new front wall built. This is basically what remains on that side of the ground today (although the roof is of course fairly new). As with the rest of the terrace, the front steps were concrete and were probably broken up as rubble. If the steps were to be rebuilt, I assume that they would have to be constructed to modern standards.

mrsenario
Gold Member
Posts: 1628
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2008 12:15 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by mrsenario » Mon Jan 23, 2012 12:48 pm

Agree with what you say here and I said a while back that I,m concerned if the study fell flat.
Even the plan you mention, whats the harm in having a 10 year plan even so everyone can get involved fundraising, shares could be sold etc having a fixed target to aim for knowing that its very achievable and even if it develops the holker end only, it would easily double the atmosphere in the ground having 2 sets of fans under one roof and lets face it, who wants to travel 6 hours from ebsfleet to stand in the rain and wind for 2 hours...I also mentioned we have cash flow problems every now and then and this fund could be used to dip into to support daz and dave to maintain their excellent progress.

lets face it on the field...the 4 year plan hasnt done to bad has it...so lets see at least a chance for the fans and all connected with the club to buy into something long term........would 30k per year be easy to achieve over 10 years and matched with a grant could get 2 floodlights and a new development???? maybee ...maybee not

Maybee the fact that theres no huge thermometer in the ground showing the target reminds the board how cold it is up there on a january night when they are looking for a good crowd to support the on field activities and wondering why the terraces are sparse........could this not be done seperatly still against a major development for the other 3 sides?????????

popsider
Senior Member
Posts: 356
Joined: Sun Aug 16, 2009 12:08 am
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by popsider » Mon Jan 23, 2012 2:25 pm

Why dont you all forget about the development of the ground if it happens it happens no amount of ideas and speculation will change things.
News is what other people dont want you to know, the rest is advertising ...........Randolph Hearst

User avatar
Wintergreen
BarrowAFC Veteran
Posts: 7525
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 12:38 pm
Location: The Blue Planet
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Wintergreen » Tue Jan 24, 2012 11:10 am

It’s never a good idea too put all your eggs in one basket, but in our case we have to as there is no cash to do anything else but to go with the current proposal.
My personal speculation is that it one of two senarios will come to pass:

Plan A
• 2016 AD, BAFC eventually get green light to proceed in tandem with partner organisation
• PFI - type approach adopted
• BAFC Holding Company (BAFCHC) activated
• BAFCHC organisation includes personnel with experience on similar projects
• BAFCHC gets BAFC assets valued and borrows on the strength of valuation
• Available grants and funding support options are maximised
• Redevelopment of stadium undertaken to include partner organisation facilities
• BAFCHC charges partner organisation rent and maintenance fees which services the loan and provides a little profit
• Football and increased revenue from new facilities further adds to BAFC income stream

Plan B
• 2016 AD, Er,
• That’s it
• Keep calm
• Play on
We will foller the soccer, over land and sea...

User avatar
barrowfan_chris
Platinum Member
Posts: 3512
Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 5:44 pm
Location: The Former Republic of Barrovia.
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by barrowfan_chris » Tue Jan 24, 2012 11:25 am

mrsenario wrote:it would easily double the atmosphere in the ground having 2 sets of fans under one roof and lets face it, who wants to travel 6 hours from ebsfleet to stand in the rain and wind for 2 hours...
Do we really care wether the away fans have a roof or not i don't. Our ground should be the focus of home fans not bloody away fans FFS. We get an open terrace at york,Ebbsfleet(if segregated),Stockport(if we took plenty),Bath(if segregated),Southport,Newport ect...

You don't create a stand for away fans to make noise you do you best to make sure they can't be heard.

Mike Wilson
Silver Member
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sat Aug 28, 2010 5:41 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Mike Wilson » Tue Jan 24, 2012 3:58 pm

Could/should the club and asda get together with the council (or who ever owns that void) and fill in that prehistoric retention pond and put the land reclaimed land to good use ? its a ugly eyesore without a purpose .
At least Mad Russell can hold on to a lead easier than BAFC

Attila
Silver Member
Posts: 1427
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2010 6:37 pm
Contact:

Re: Holker Street Development

Post by Attila » Tue Jan 24, 2012 6:33 pm

Mike Wilson wrote:Could/should the club and asda get together with the council (or who ever owns that void) and fill in that prehistoric retention pond and put the land reclaimed land to good use ? its a ugly eyesore without a purpose .
Probably get the tree hugging brigade on your case with that Mike as I think a frog lives there.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bohemians Praha 1905 and 13 guests