Salford City FC (H) match thread
- Mark Johnson
- Gold Member
- Posts: 2333
- Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 3:04 pm
- Location: London
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
Subs should be made when things aren't going quite right (which is the case in a lot of games). Today, however, we were absolutely on top and seemed like a goal was imminent .. Really don't understand the subs today.
But I agree that Wild on the whole is pretty decent with sub making decisions. Think it was 2 points dropped today, but a lot of positives to take out of the performace on the whole
But I agree that Wild on the whole is pretty decent with sub making decisions. Think it was 2 points dropped today, but a lot of positives to take out of the performace on the whole
-
blue nige
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 7223
- Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2013 7:21 pm
- Location: Antarctica
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
We could have done with those 2 today !Adam29 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:40 pm Aside from the game itself it was lovely seeing Simon Wiles today.
There was a lovely reunion between himself and Jason Walker prior to the players coming out to warm up.
Came up to the press box to reminisce over the old time’s looking at the old photos on the wall
IMG_1691.jpeg
Re: Salford City FC (H)
Agree that we lacked the impetus Foley brings having to utilise him in defence due to the Feely injury.Main Stand SeasonTct wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:27 pmI think the injury to Feely forcing him to make his final substitution put a spanner in the works. He was forced to move Foley to centre half negating Foleys driving ability in midfield and making defence splitting passes that has proved fruitful on more than one occasion this seasonJim wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:20 pm
Can't agree with that. Usually, Wild's subs make a difference in a positive way and I don't think giving then game time to keep them happy is in his mind at all. I do agree that, listening today, it sounded as though we went off the boil from the time of the substitutions.
Feely felt his hamstring which will mean James Chester will return Tuesday after being rested today
Ell Newby just couldn’t beat the first man today but like us Salford were very organised at the back. After a decent first half they grew into the game more pushing higher up the field. We created next to nothing second half. Ray was outstanding today Gotts had a good game too but that card was deserved unless he slipped. It was too far away to determine one way or another. Defensively we are certainly at it and will definitely need to be on Tuesday night.
-
Main Stand SeasonTct
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3328
- Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2017 5:05 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H)
If he had put Stephenson at right back who goes to left back? Newby at left wing back and Whits at right wing back was giving us joy down both flanks it just wasn’t falling for us in the final third similar problem as last Saturday. KTF it will come. We are a very decent side much better than last season IMO. The difference is the standard of league 2 this season compared to last. For me the quality is much better this season and many sides including us have improved.blue nige wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:39 pmBut he didn't we're at home put Stephenson at right back and keep Foley in midfield ,we're supposed to take the initiative at home not play not to get beat, we have to be more proactive, they only had Smith up front we didn't need 3 central defenders this nearly cost us the game ,Salford are not world beaters yet the respect we give team's when we're at home is ridiculous!Main Stand SeasonTct wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:27 pm
I think the injury to Feely forcing him to make his final substitution put a spanner in the works. He was forced to move Foley to centre half negating Foleys driving ability in midfield and making defence splitting passes that has proved fruitful on more than one occasion this season
Feely felt his hamstring which will mean James Chester will return Tuesday after being rested today
- 32mile_cul-de-sac
- Gold Member
- Posts: 2447
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 8:14 pm
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
Salford for me never came and had a go, again final third let us down. Would like Acquah to get nasty, has everything but that nastiness good forwards have. Saying that he is learning and hope that part of his game comes good in time. Lot of crosses today never beat the first man with big lads waiting for the service. If it was a boxing match we would have won on points but alas it isn't. Big George MOTM for me.
-
Suffolk Blue
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3810
- Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 6:09 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
My first trip to HS this season. Over the years I must have seen most of our encounters with Salford home and away. I can quite honestly say that was the most dominant performance I’ve seen us give against them.
Pete Wils was right when he said that much of our game plan worked. Thought our work out of possession was outstanding. We pressed them in their own half really well - I’m assuming this was to limit them pumping balls up to Smith. His threat was totally wiped out. Canavan and Ray were top class.
At the other end we forced them to play 5 at the back for most of the game which they did pretty well so probably deserved their point - just..
We worked hard to carve out chances and there were some excellent moves that just didn’t get a proper finish. If I have a concern, it’s more to with the speed of transition into attack. Our attacks too often run out of pace as we approach the opposition area and to be honest we seem to overthink situations.
It’ll be just as hard on Tuesday.
Pete Wils was right when he said that much of our game plan worked. Thought our work out of possession was outstanding. We pressed them in their own half really well - I’m assuming this was to limit them pumping balls up to Smith. His threat was totally wiped out. Canavan and Ray were top class.
At the other end we forced them to play 5 at the back for most of the game which they did pretty well so probably deserved their point - just..
We worked hard to carve out chances and there were some excellent moves that just didn’t get a proper finish. If I have a concern, it’s more to with the speed of transition into attack. Our attacks too often run out of pace as we approach the opposition area and to be honest we seem to overthink situations.
It’ll be just as hard on Tuesday.
-
blue nige
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 7223
- Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2013 7:21 pm
- Location: Antarctica
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H)
Please read what I wrote!Main Stand SeasonTct wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:50 pmblue nige wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:39 pm
But he didn't we're at home put Stephenson at right back and keep Foley in midfield ,we're supposed to take the initiative at home not play not to get beat, we have to be more proactive, they only had Smith up front we didn't need 3 central defenders this nearly cost us the game ,Salford are not world beaters yet the respect we give team's when we're at home is ridiculous!
If he had put Stephenson at right back who goes to left back? Newby at left wing back and Whits at right wing back was giving us joy down both flanks it just wasn’t falling for us in the final third similar problem as last Saturday. KTF it will come. We are a very decent side much better than last season IMO. The difference is the standard of league 2 this season compared to last. For me the quality is much better this season and many sides including us have improved.
A flat back 4
Newby and Stephenson fullbacks.
Whitfield moves forward,
We need to win games at home yet by sticking with the 3 central defenders it gave Salford the initiative !
-
Main Stand SeasonTct
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3328
- Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2017 5:05 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H)
Since when was Newby a Left back? He is an attacking left wing back and you could see Salford were very wary of him. Stephenson was signed as midfielder who can fill in at right back. Listening to Wild after the game he said that Foley played at CH in a recent B team game and was confident he could do a job. It was the correct move IMO but one that was forced due to Feely getting injured. The 3 centre half's and attacking wing backs negated Salfords threat to minimal chances so the plan worked IMO.blue nige wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 8:24 pmPlease read what I wrote!Main Stand SeasonTct wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:50 pm
If he had put Stephenson at right back who goes to left back? Newby at left wing back and Whits at right wing back was giving us joy down both flanks it just wasn’t falling for us in the final third similar problem as last Saturday. KTF it will come. We are a very decent side much better than last season IMO. The difference is the standard of league 2 this season compared to last. For me the quality is much better this season and many sides including us have improved.
A flat back 4
Newby and Stephenson fullbacks.
Whitfield moves forward,
We need to win games at home yet by sticking with the 3 central defenders it gave Salford the initiative !
-
blue nige
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 7223
- Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2013 7:21 pm
- Location: Antarctica
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H)
Are you for real ,? They played with Smith by himself, we're at home we're not playing away for a draw. It's negative thinking by our manager, our thoughts should be about entertaining and trying to win not playing to contain teams ,that's why we'll start losing crowds !Main Stand SeasonTct wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 8:32 pmSince when was Newby a Left back? He is an attacking left wing back and you could see Salford were very wary of him. Stephenson was signed as midfielder who can fill in at right back. Listening to Wild after the game he said that Foley played at CH in a recent B team game and was confident he could do a job. It was the correct move IMO but one that was forced due to Feely getting injured. The 3 centre half's and attacking wing backs negated Salfords threat to minimal chances so the plan worked IMO.
-
saltcellar
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 2868
- Joined: Mon Jun 22, 2009 7:44 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H)
Telford looked to be limping when he came off.mickycarrol wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:10 pmSometimes feel Wild makes changes just to try and keep people happy with game time. No need at all to bring Garner on today. Offered nothing different to Telford and did absolutely zero when on as you rightly say. Needs front pair to build up a relationship and get to know one another. Constant change up top won’t help build this.
Maybe that was the reason.
-
ossickbluebird
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 647
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 8:43 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
Wouldn't it be great if football was about entertaining, but it's not. It's about gaining points where you can and hopefully, at the end of the season, having enough to either go up automatically or be in the play-offs, thats it.
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
Yes. We might criticise Wild’s decisions but for me the time to judge him will be at the end of the season. He says he is happy that the team is on track and the points tally is what he expects, so we won’t know whether he is a brilliant strategist or unduly optimistic until it’s over.ossickbluebird wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 9:16 pm Wouldn't it be great if football was about entertaining, but it's not. It's about gaining points where you can and hopefully, at the end of the season, having enough to either go up automatically or be in the play-offs, thats it.
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
If there's one thing that frustrates me a little about Wild's interviews in recent weeks it's the "we should be happy with this" because of the stature and resources of that the teams we are playing against. Same when he says any point away from home is a good one when that's not necessarily the case if you know you're better than the opposition. His first answer in today's BBC interview was about how he felt the game went well because we nullified Salford's threats (which we did excellently, Smith hardly had a touch), but I feel we should focus on more what we can do rather than being overly concerned about the problems the opposition can pose.
I'm not trying to be critical, because he's getting great, solid results over the course of his tenure which we all hoped we'd get in those first couple of seasons and I'm looking forward to seeing how far he can take us. But we've proven now that we deserve to stay and compete at this level, why not try being a bit more front footed about the way we talk about ourselves?
I'm not trying to be critical, because he's getting great, solid results over the course of his tenure which we all hoped we'd get in those first couple of seasons and I'm looking forward to seeing how far he can take us. But we've proven now that we deserve to stay and compete at this level, why not try being a bit more front footed about the way we talk about ourselves?
Popular side since '03.
-
Main Stand SeasonTct
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3328
- Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2017 5:05 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
He aint wrong though. In recent weeks we aint lost to Notts County, Wimbledon and now Salford who all have vastly superior financial resources to us. We have a punchers chance to get in the playoffs IMO as to whether we can punch above our weight and reach them time will tell.Matty wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 10:04 pm If there's one thing that frustrates me a little about Wild's interviews in recent weeks it's the "we should be happy with this" because of the stature and resources of that the teams we are playing against. Same when he says any point away from home is a good one when that's not necessarily the case if you know you're better than the opposition. His first answer in today's BBC interview was about how he felt the game went well because we nullified Salford's threats (which we did excellently, Smith hardly had a touch), but I feel we should focus on more what we can do rather than being overly concerned about the problems the opposition can pose.
I'm not trying to be critical, because he's getting great, solid results over the course of his tenure which we all hoped we'd get in those first couple of seasons and I'm looking forward to seeing how far he can take us. But we've proven now that we deserve to stay and compete at this level, why not try being a bit more front footed about the way we talk about ourselves?
Re: Salford City FC (H) match thread
So disappointed with the attendance today. If I can be bothered coming up for the second 0-0 draw in a week, this time with all my grandkids, then why can't the great Barrow public get out to support the best team we've had for decades. I know I'm preaching to the converted on here as many of you are regulars. We now have enough covering and seats in the ground to avoid getting drenched, the fanzone and crossbar are good places to have a drink etc so why did less than 3000 Barrow fans turn up to today? And don't give me that excuse for the weather please.
As for the game I enjoyed last week much more. Again we let Salford play for the first 20 mins or so then dominated them without looking threatening until the subs came on with injuries also playing a part and then we lost all cohesion going forward. There appears to be a lack of awareness up front a bit more sharpness in the closing down of their defenders could have seen us grabbing a goal - just look at the panic a bit of pressure did that led to the poor back pass by them leading to the indirect free kick. Sadly very unimpressed with Garner - didn't look interested (but that could be lack of confidence). Though Telford was OK and didn't feel he should have been subbed. Feel we need Proctor back asap to help the forwards out.
Bit frustrated with it all today.
As for the game I enjoyed last week much more. Again we let Salford play for the first 20 mins or so then dominated them without looking threatening until the subs came on with injuries also playing a part and then we lost all cohesion going forward. There appears to be a lack of awareness up front a bit more sharpness in the closing down of their defenders could have seen us grabbing a goal - just look at the panic a bit of pressure did that led to the poor back pass by them leading to the indirect free kick. Sadly very unimpressed with Garner - didn't look interested (but that could be lack of confidence). Though Telford was OK and didn't feel he should have been subbed. Feel we need Proctor back asap to help the forwards out.
Bit frustrated with it all today.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests