Holker Street Development
- Steelworks End
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 5959
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 6:03 pm
- Location: Twickenham
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
The Bluebird Club was built by Barrow AFC a tad over 40 years ago, and subsequently sold, I would guess, because it was losing money. What would be different now, I wonder? As the building is up for sale at around £150,000, down from £200,000, it can hardly be a licence to print money. Also, as has been mentioned, it would be competing with the Crossbar, and also the non-club owned Soccer Bar (Blackbird).
Arguably, the Bluebird is better placed to attract supporters coming up Holker Street than either of the other two bars, but I wonder what percentage of fans come that way now - probably down quite a lot since the A590 into Barrow was re-routed away from Abbey Road and past the ground. For many motorists, car parking is more convenient near to the Crossbar than the Bluebird. Whichever ways supporters come to the ground, if both the Crossbar and the Bluebired co-existed, they would be competing for the same trade.
So the Bluebird is only likely to be viable - if at all - as a replacement for the Crossbar, and that is there for the duration until any redevelopment of the ground takes place. Of course, if redevelopment of the ground does take place then the Bluebird would be somewhat in the way - or ideally placed, depending on your viewpoint.
If Barrow AFC had £150,000 to spare, then it may be advantageous to buy the Bluebird now, if only to get our hands on the site in the event of redevelopment going ahead. But can we afford to do that? Somehow, I think not.
Arguably, the Bluebird is better placed to attract supporters coming up Holker Street than either of the other two bars, but I wonder what percentage of fans come that way now - probably down quite a lot since the A590 into Barrow was re-routed away from Abbey Road and past the ground. For many motorists, car parking is more convenient near to the Crossbar than the Bluebird. Whichever ways supporters come to the ground, if both the Crossbar and the Bluebired co-existed, they would be competing for the same trade.
So the Bluebird is only likely to be viable - if at all - as a replacement for the Crossbar, and that is there for the duration until any redevelopment of the ground takes place. Of course, if redevelopment of the ground does take place then the Bluebird would be somewhat in the way - or ideally placed, depending on your viewpoint.
If Barrow AFC had £150,000 to spare, then it may be advantageous to buy the Bluebird now, if only to get our hands on the site in the event of redevelopment going ahead. But can we afford to do that? Somehow, I think not.
- Electricblues
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 644
- Joined: Wed Jul 28, 2010 9:58 am
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
I reckon the club should buy it and turn it into one of those lapdancing clubs. Bound to make a fortune, could call it 'Bluetits'.
Re: Holker Street Development
I don't take the view of it competing with the Crossbar. I take the view that it would initially enhance the clubs capability to provide choice for supporters and if the crossbar end comes down as part of the plan then the club would still have a facility to generate matchday income and provide supporters with a bar. Ultimately, if redevelopment goes ahead i just think it would be better Barrow afc owned than owned some other party who could take away custom and then make things difficult during any future redvelopment. Think about it positively- that having it would prevent any future issues with development. "Welcome to our ground, but just ignore this run downclub club, with the manky stench its nothing to do with us" Yes money now but bought as part of the longer term development. Otherwise continue to breath in matchday fumes only sat in some seats in a stand that has been built around an old building will just be there-in the way. Are you kidding? Do you think other clubs would leave it as part of their grand plans? no?. I do not want to see a half arsed attempt at this redevelopment. It has to be right-it is the development of for the next 75 years. If development doesn't happen at HS,then we move onto the next plan and if its away from HS or a joint stadium venture then lets see the plans. What I don't want is something half done.
Last edited by Jonty on Thu Dec 01, 2011 6:10 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.
-
Matty Bassdriver
- Senior Member
- Posts: 465
- Joined: Fri Aug 21, 2009 1:08 pm
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
The Bluebird should never have been sold - very bad decision. No doubt at the time the club were desperate for money to keep the wolf from the door, but this was a very short termist decision with no thought about the future. It would have been more sensible to retain ownership & lease the building out to produce rental income, but retain the freehold so as to keep ultimate control of the site.
I suspect the current owner (or his lenders) - judging by the speed with which the asking price has shot down - is(are) desperate to sell this asset. I would be very surprised if anyone would be willing to buy the property for more than £100k in the current economic climate - they might even be willing to sell for a cheeky offer of say £50k.
Business rates alone on this building are in the region of £10k per annum (amount payable is current 42.6p in the £1 of rateable value), so no doubt something of a liability for the current owners:
http://www.2010.voa.gov.uk/rli/en/basic ... 9362805000
If our ground development/redevelopment is ever going to happen it would be good for the club to own the Bluebird. I wonder if the board have made an aporoach to the current owners to ascertain the likelihood of the selling to the club and if so what price they might be willing to accept? I'm sure us fans could have a crack at raising a few bob for such a worthy cause if the need arose!
I suspect the current owner (or his lenders) - judging by the speed with which the asking price has shot down - is(are) desperate to sell this asset. I would be very surprised if anyone would be willing to buy the property for more than £100k in the current economic climate - they might even be willing to sell for a cheeky offer of say £50k.
Business rates alone on this building are in the region of £10k per annum (amount payable is current 42.6p in the £1 of rateable value), so no doubt something of a liability for the current owners:
http://www.2010.voa.gov.uk/rli/en/basic ... 9362805000
If our ground development/redevelopment is ever going to happen it would be good for the club to own the Bluebird. I wonder if the board have made an aporoach to the current owners to ascertain the likelihood of the selling to the club and if so what price they might be willing to accept? I'm sure us fans could have a crack at raising a few bob for such a worthy cause if the need arose!
Last edited by Matty Bassdriver on Fri Dec 02, 2011 12:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Holker Street Development
The Bluebird Club was sold to service the football clubs expenditure and primarily its debts,just as the clubs houses were sold beforehand-I remember it well.The Bluebird Club never did run at a loss and indeed if it hadn't been for that clubhouse along with Geoff Hargreaves,Bill McCullough,and Max Rattray god bless their souls the football club would have gone under long ago.
- Nigel Bamford
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 2700
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 5:09 pm
- Location: Between here and gone
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
No, think about it realistically. It would be completely foolhardy to take the 'everything will be alright' approach. The club cannot afford it, that's it. Finish. Finito benito.Jonty wrote:Think about it positively- that having it would prevent any future issues with development.
It all comes 'round again.
-
mickycarrol
- Silver Member
- Posts: 1401
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 7:45 pm
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
I hope nowt changes n we keep HS's character, today I froze my balls off then [SwearFilter] in a hole in the floor, then battled for shelter from storms n gales. Same time next week to do it all again......
"The trouble with referees is that they know the rules, but they dont know the game"
Bill Shankly
Bill Shankly
- John Very Little
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 4136
- Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2008 3:32 am
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
If you look at the plans there will be a large stand where the Cross Bar is now so we would need another clubhouse and changing rooms etc. I think that a done-up Bluebird Club may be better than a new clubhouse under the proposed new stand? Would also eliminate problems with planning and construction issues if we do win the development.Nigel Bamford wrote:No, think about it realistically. It would be completely foolhardy to take the 'everything will be alright' approach. The club cannot afford it, that's it. Finish. Finito benito.Jonty wrote:Think about it positively- that having it would prevent any future issues with development.
Was mentioned by TK that the changing rooms would be under the new stand as well as reception, meeting rooms and hospitality areas, would there be enough room for a clubhouse as well?
- Fartvs Antiqvvs
- Silver Member
- Posts: 1417
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 4:55 pm
- Location: Nailsworth, Glos.
Re: Holker Street Development
From own experience here, works OK if you get the right developer and thereafter, an interested owner with the right sort of clout.Paul wrote:Well said that man. We've needed a new ground/major improvements for decades, and now that we have a chance of these becomingDavy T wrote:Let's be honest,our ground is lost in time and has needed an upgrade for decades.
If I was told these plans 3 years ago,I would have laughed in the face of the person telling me and now it's a reality(fingers crossed) but still people are moaning?You can't please some people.I guess people are stuck in the 40's and afraid of change,plus they must enjoy p!ssing in a gutter and it splashing on their shoes!
LET'S GET REAL PEOPLE.....SITTING OR STANDING THESE PLANS ARE FANTASTIC!
a reallity, all some people can do is moan about the proposed plans. Let's all support these plans for the future of our beloved football
club, we might never get another shot at this.
Completed 2006 and now pushing on with further development utilising the "away' stand roof.

Non essere curioso!
- Wintergreen
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 7525
- Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 12:38 pm
- Location: The Blue Planet
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
The winter is only beginning and we’ve already had parts of our ground sectioned off on matchdays and closure of the surrounding streets due to unsafe structures on our ancient pile. We need to know where we stand right now – we have to have an answer from the partner organisation at this month’s meeting - yea or nay.
The procrastination is allowing FBSS/HS to deteriorate badly and if we do not start some form of investment/refurbishment soon we may have stadium closures or someone being injured/killed on the site and imagine the fall out from that as all our good progress will come grinding to a halt.
It doesn't pay to court disaster.
The procrastination is allowing FBSS/HS to deteriorate badly and if we do not start some form of investment/refurbishment soon we may have stadium closures or someone being injured/killed on the site and imagine the fall out from that as all our good progress will come grinding to a halt.
It doesn't pay to court disaster.
We will foller the soccer, over land and sea...
- Steelworks End
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 5959
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 6:03 pm
- Location: Twickenham
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
For as long as I can remember, Holker Street has been maintained - to use the expression loosely - on the basis of only doing things when absolutely necessary, and then with demolition being the preferred option. The roofs on the Popular Side and the Holker End were removed because they were dangerous; the former was replaced eventually thanks largely to the supporters' "Raise the Roof" campaign, the latter terrace is still of course uncovered. And the old Grandstand was condemned along with similar structures elsewhere following the Bradford fire. Supporters of a certain age will also remember buckets on the floor of the Crossbar, strategically placed below the worst leaks from the flat roof. And as for the toilets ..... !Wintergreen wrote:The winter is only beginning and we’ve already had parts of our ground sectioned off on matchdays and closure of the surrounding streets due to unsafe structures on our ancient pile.
With regards to the floodlight pylons, they (or at least the three remaining original ones) are the best part of half a century old and have survived with minimal maintenance - as far as I'm aware - over that period. Pylons of this type are becoming increasingly rare; if we are not careful we may find that someone has applied for them to become a listed building / structure, with all that that entails.
Money, or lack thereof, has been the reason behind this, of course. It is understandable that, until the outcome of the feasibility study is revealed, that the club is only spending what it has to on a decaying infrastructure. But if a major ground redevelopment dosen't materialise, is there a Plan B to bring the facilities up to a decent standard?
Until the repairs are completed, as far away from the pylons as possible!Wintergreen wrote: We need to know where we stand right now
- Wintergreen
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 7525
- Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 12:38 pm
- Location: The Blue Planet
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
Good post and another valid point regarding the pylons’ potentially having a ‘listed building/structure’ status; some anti-AFC busybody might instigate such a claim.
The outcome of the Feasibility Study has been revealed – we have a chance of developing FBSS/HS with an interested partner organisation who unfortunately for us have many other priorities and are used to doing things at a snail’s pace.
Hopefully there is a Plan B and hopefully that plan has the pylons as first priority –in the present H&S climate they can’t be too far off permanent condemnation by the Council or HSE. However, in such cash-strapped times the likelihood of a major investment by the partner organisation is looking bleaker by the week in my opinion.
The partner organisation HAS to be pressed at the next meeting for a decision before we are all locked out and watching BAFC elsewhere.
The outcome of the Feasibility Study has been revealed – we have a chance of developing FBSS/HS with an interested partner organisation who unfortunately for us have many other priorities and are used to doing things at a snail’s pace.
Hopefully there is a Plan B and hopefully that plan has the pylons as first priority –in the present H&S climate they can’t be too far off permanent condemnation by the Council or HSE. However, in such cash-strapped times the likelihood of a major investment by the partner organisation is looking bleaker by the week in my opinion.
The partner organisation HAS to be pressed at the next meeting for a decision before we are all locked out and watching BAFC elsewhere.
We will foller the soccer, over land and sea...
- Wintergreen
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 7525
- Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 12:38 pm
- Location: The Blue Planet
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
My reasoning comes from the fact that I worked in construction for 30+ years and have always put safety first, I have had plenty of rows with plenty of people on plenty of sites home and abroad about safety.
Looking at those pylons – the person responsible for them with a duty of care to the public, must be having kittens every time the wind blows because he/she will be the one who will end up in a court of law facing serious charges in the event of an accident.
The pylons are a major risk and they are putting the club at risk – we need to deal with the risk ASAP.
Looking at those pylons – the person responsible for them with a duty of care to the public, must be having kittens every time the wind blows because he/she will be the one who will end up in a court of law facing serious charges in the event of an accident.
The pylons are a major risk and they are putting the club at risk – we need to deal with the risk ASAP.
We will foller the soccer, over land and sea...
Re: Holker Street Development
I'm thinking about a Plan B for ground development. Everything would need to be to league requirements of course.
- Refurbish existing floodlights- or replace one by one so they are all like the newer one. Do you think our floodlights can be saved? Has anyone actually conducted a structual assesment of the pylons with a view to saving them? The four main legs of each look to be in reasonable condition and so do most of the cross members. The newer pylon is only about 5 years old. On the other three, The ladders and the cages themselves are what need the work. Maybe a local fabrication / Engineering firm could get onboard and strike a deal with the club- (Main Shirt Sponsorship maybe?) in return for refurbishment over the next season.
- "Goal Post style" structure for HS End Roof- no need to knock down and replace existing terrace- A single span goalpost style framework from each corner would support the entire roof, unobstructed. Re build back wall street side. This is the cheapest stadium roof design.
- replace missing Popside terrace Steps- backdown to pitch side- as it was.
- Build Cross Bar 2, moving changerooms into Popside/ Crossbar corner, block existing tunnel and this becomes the away end. Include revenue making facilities- ie conference rooms, BAFC gym, BAFC health spa, BAFC business lets, etc- all revenues coming to us, . Full hospitality suites upstairs. - Green thinking - solar panels on Crossbar roof, (small revenue stream for club). Study centre, etc.
- new playing surface.
purchase Bluebirdclub, turn it into a successful matchday revenue stream, function suite.
- Extend Main Stand to full length of pitch. Additional floodlighing along roof edge-(like Craven Park main stand)
newturnstyle systems
any QS out there?- How much for all that then?
Any aspiring new board members- Never mind the sarnies- HS Development is your strategic focus.- We need to explore all alternatives.
Plan B views? - is this doable?, would it be more cost effective than the total rebuild shown on the feasibility study?? Funded by sponsorships of everything and whatever sports grants we can secure.
- Refurbish existing floodlights- or replace one by one so they are all like the newer one. Do you think our floodlights can be saved? Has anyone actually conducted a structual assesment of the pylons with a view to saving them? The four main legs of each look to be in reasonable condition and so do most of the cross members. The newer pylon is only about 5 years old. On the other three, The ladders and the cages themselves are what need the work. Maybe a local fabrication / Engineering firm could get onboard and strike a deal with the club- (Main Shirt Sponsorship maybe?) in return for refurbishment over the next season.
- "Goal Post style" structure for HS End Roof- no need to knock down and replace existing terrace- A single span goalpost style framework from each corner would support the entire roof, unobstructed. Re build back wall street side. This is the cheapest stadium roof design.
- replace missing Popside terrace Steps- backdown to pitch side- as it was.
- Build Cross Bar 2, moving changerooms into Popside/ Crossbar corner, block existing tunnel and this becomes the away end. Include revenue making facilities- ie conference rooms, BAFC gym, BAFC health spa, BAFC business lets, etc- all revenues coming to us, . Full hospitality suites upstairs. - Green thinking - solar panels on Crossbar roof, (small revenue stream for club). Study centre, etc.
- new playing surface.
purchase Bluebirdclub, turn it into a successful matchday revenue stream, function suite.
- Extend Main Stand to full length of pitch. Additional floodlighing along roof edge-(like Craven Park main stand)
newturnstyle systems
any QS out there?- How much for all that then?
Any aspiring new board members- Never mind the sarnies- HS Development is your strategic focus.- We need to explore all alternatives.
Plan B views? - is this doable?, would it be more cost effective than the total rebuild shown on the feasibility study?? Funded by sponsorships of everything and whatever sports grants we can secure.
"To achieve anything and to get to the Football League, we have to expect to win every game. I've got to get everyone believing that we can, and I will work hard to embed that mentality into the players, the town, the board and whoever else” Ian Evatt.
-
barrowscuba
- Member
- Posts: 193
- Joined: Mon Jun 09, 2008 6:07 pm
- Contact:
Re: Holker Street Development
Don't you think your plan b would have already been actioned if it was so simple? You don't appear to appreciate how much work costs and the fact that the club don't have enough money to run on a day to day basis never mind paying to upgrade the ground to a reasonable standard.
I believe that Chas Kendall paid around £10k a year for shirt sponsorship. That might buy a few bulbs, not three new floodlight pylons.
The goalpost style roof ...what do you plan on securing the goalposts to? It's been well documented in the past that new foundations would be required for any new terracing/stand/roofing at the Holker Street End and that the foundations have been costed at £250K alone.
Purchase Bluebird Club & build Crossbar 2 ...... where's the money coming from.
Fundamental flaws in all your ideas sorry. It all boils down to cold hard cash and we dont have any.
I believe that Chas Kendall paid around £10k a year for shirt sponsorship. That might buy a few bulbs, not three new floodlight pylons.
The goalpost style roof ...what do you plan on securing the goalposts to? It's been well documented in the past that new foundations would be required for any new terracing/stand/roofing at the Holker Street End and that the foundations have been costed at £250K alone.
Purchase Bluebird Club & build Crossbar 2 ...... where's the money coming from.
Fundamental flaws in all your ideas sorry. It all boils down to cold hard cash and we dont have any.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot], Baxterj732, greenarmour, spirit of 1990 and 31 guests