I agree that sometimes communication from the club is poor but in today's circumstance they can only say what they have been told by the referee. By the sounds of things they were told it was on at 9am and off at 12.30. At 9 he couldn't have said to Macclesfield 'wait and see how it is later' because then they wouldn't have made it in time for kick off. Poor decision making by the referee, if he had serious doubts he should've called it off after the first inspection. Saying that, however, it is beyond me how an improvement in weather conditions causes a deterioration of pitch conditions.Always Ultra wrote:My issue with the club is not so much about failing to get the game on, but more about another case of poor communication with fans. It wasn't that long ago that a car crash caused a similar situation, leaving people not knowing if/when the game was going to go ahead.Matty wrote:I don't think this is the club's fault whatsoever.
game off
Re: game off
Popular side since '03.
Re: game off
That's it in a nutshell.Matty wrote:By the sounds of things they were told it was on at 9am and off at 12.30.
The club have responded when they have information, nothing wrong with communications except those with the ref from what I hear. Everyone (both clubs and their fans) are angry and some fans are looking for a scapegoat. I would ask people to not point the finger at the club, the pitch from all accounts was playable today but the ref for some unexplained reason said no. It makes Barrow look bad in the eyes of the Macc fans and those Barrow supporters that don't think highly of the club in general. Todays decision seems to lie with an unexplained U-turn on the part of the ref, who came back after lunch and said no.
Re: game off
I have heard from a very reliable source that the ref passed the pitch fit at 9.30 based on the forecast and how is assumed the pitch would react to that forecast.
However, when he returned, he said although the pitch was playable, there would be area's of the pitch where players would move from one type of surface to another, which might cause a problem.
The covers were apparently on since Wednesday. Which, suggests that they are completely useless considering that there hasn't exactly been a hard frost all week.
Despite protestations from both camps, he was unmoved.
Macclesfield don't have any kind of problem with us but overall, this postponement has cost us approximately £1.8k (£~800 match official costs/expenses and £1k for Macc's wasted journey).
However, when he returned, he said although the pitch was playable, there would be area's of the pitch where players would move from one type of surface to another, which might cause a problem.
The covers were apparently on since Wednesday. Which, suggests that they are completely useless considering that there hasn't exactly been a hard frost all week.
Despite protestations from both camps, he was unmoved.
Macclesfield don't have any kind of problem with us but overall, this postponement has cost us approximately £1.8k (£~800 match official costs/expenses and £1k for Macc's wasted journey).
The views expressed on this site are my own and do reflect the views of my employer
Re: game off
Reg.Reg wrote:I have heard from a very reliable source that the ref passed the pitch fit at 9.30 based on the forecast and how is assumed the pitch would react to that forecast.
However, when he returned, he said although the pitch was playable, there would be area's of the pitch where players would move from one type of surface to another, which might cause a problem.
The covers were apparently on since Wednesday. Which, suggests that they are completely useless considering that there hasn't exactly been a hard frost all week.
Despite protestations from both camps, he was unmoved.
Macclesfield don't have any kind of problem with us but overall, this postponement has cost us approximately £1.8k (£~800 match official costs/expenses and £1k for Macc's wasted journey).
Think of the Stewards will you!! How will i ever get in when the games on a tuesday?

Justin you bummer. Your hound is shaggin someone else!
"F*cking Ribble" - Steve Herbert 26/4/09
Re: game off
Sounds the most likely explanation. Both teams were not concerned but the buck stops with the ref. If he did not want to take responsibility for it than we can not argue, those are the rules.Reg wrote:I have heard from a very reliable source that the ref passed the pitch fit at 9.30 based on the forecast and how is assumed the pitch would react to that forecast.
However, when he returned, he said although the pitch was playable, there would be area's of the pitch where players would move from one type of surface to another, which might cause a problem.
-
Bingo
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 4105
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2008 12:43 am
- Location: Failsworth, Manchester
- Contact:
Re: game off
watching the fa cup highlights programme - have you seen the state of the pitch at Harrogate town
-
saltcellar
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 2867
- Joined: Mon Jun 22, 2009 7:44 pm
- Contact:
Re: game off
The referee is allowed to claim up to £100 for a hotel stay.barrowaberdeen wrote:The ref has claimed for an overnight stay and extras will see him geting the thick end of 700 quid.
Sorry they had to to miss it, massive whoppers though they were.
Also allowed to claim 40p a mile travelling (coming from the north east probably equates to another £100)
He is entitled to half his £315 match fee, but this is payable by the FA and not Barrow.
Reports seem to suggest all officials stopped overnight at the Whitewater Hotel.
I cannot see any justification for an overnight hotel stay for officials travelling from the North East.
That is a journey of less than 4 hours.
Maybe Barrow requested the referee to attend early for the 9-30 inspection, but surely there was no justification for all the officials have to stayed overnight.
All in all a costly experience for the club.
Did anybody watch the cup highlights on ITV and see two gentlemen sticking car keys in the ground in front of the pop side.
They seemed to have no trouble sticking them all the way in.
Who were they as they certainly were not the referee?
-
Si_Nichols
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 663
- Joined: Wed Jun 03, 2009 8:45 pm
- Location: Lancaster
- Contact:
Re: game off
Shambles is the only word.
It is fair to say that at 2pm I was fuming but have calmed down a bit now. Having left the house just before 7am this morning I got picked up by Darren Riley just off the M25 and we headed north with a back-up plan to go see a game in the Midlands if he worst happened and the game was called off. When we got news of the initial pitch inspection we were just south of Birmingham and were chuffed to bits.
Our first problem of the day was not too far away however as somebody thought it was a good idea to allow an "abnormal" load travel up the M6 at 10mph taking up two lanes and subsequently closing the bridge across the Manchester ship canal due to the weight of it whilst they got it across. With huge tailbacks we were forced into taking a detour through Congleton and skirting the south side of Manchester. We were worried for a while that we were going to miss kick-off (a prophecy that did indeed come true but now in the expected way) but after taking the M60 & M61 up to Preston we made good time and we were just coming out of Ulverston at 1340.
It was then that I looked at twitter on my phone to be totally aghast at the news. I initially thought someone was having a joke. Now too late to do anything else we headed to the ground to have it confirmed that the game was indeed off. Unfortunately with a specific train home booked (to try and save some money) - the 1944 from Lancaster - I was now left with several hours to kill before being able to head home. A few beers and a visit to my auntie was what I decided on before heading back. I eventually got in my door at ten past midnight, so nearly 17 and a half hours after I had left.
So 17+ hours (of which 12+ I spent travelling), 550+ miles and approx £100 all wasted. A day of my life I will never get back. Whoever is to blame (and whilst I think a lot of this is the ref I am not sure he is the only one at fault), thanks a bunch. I certainly won't ever be travelling to Holker St again if there is even a shred of doubt about the game being on.
At least the FA Trophy 2nd round is just down the road for me
It is fair to say that at 2pm I was fuming but have calmed down a bit now. Having left the house just before 7am this morning I got picked up by Darren Riley just off the M25 and we headed north with a back-up plan to go see a game in the Midlands if he worst happened and the game was called off. When we got news of the initial pitch inspection we were just south of Birmingham and were chuffed to bits.
Our first problem of the day was not too far away however as somebody thought it was a good idea to allow an "abnormal" load travel up the M6 at 10mph taking up two lanes and subsequently closing the bridge across the Manchester ship canal due to the weight of it whilst they got it across. With huge tailbacks we were forced into taking a detour through Congleton and skirting the south side of Manchester. We were worried for a while that we were going to miss kick-off (a prophecy that did indeed come true but now in the expected way) but after taking the M60 & M61 up to Preston we made good time and we were just coming out of Ulverston at 1340.
It was then that I looked at twitter on my phone to be totally aghast at the news. I initially thought someone was having a joke. Now too late to do anything else we headed to the ground to have it confirmed that the game was indeed off. Unfortunately with a specific train home booked (to try and save some money) - the 1944 from Lancaster - I was now left with several hours to kill before being able to head home. A few beers and a visit to my auntie was what I decided on before heading back. I eventually got in my door at ten past midnight, so nearly 17 and a half hours after I had left.
So 17+ hours (of which 12+ I spent travelling), 550+ miles and approx £100 all wasted. A day of my life I will never get back. Whoever is to blame (and whilst I think a lot of this is the ref I am not sure he is the only one at fault), thanks a bunch. I certainly won't ever be travelling to Holker St again if there is even a shred of doubt about the game being on.
At least the FA Trophy 2nd round is just down the road for me
Re: game off
Did he say that or did he say it looked OK but would be subject to a further inspection of the area causing the trouble?K_BFC wrote:If the Macc (and Barrow) fans that traveled in vain today have any doubt, they should direct their disappointment at the ref.
He turned up and said game on first thing this morning.
Some are suggesting the latter in which case the information given after the first inspection wasn't correct.
game off
If the officials really were from north east and stayed overnight that is ridiculous. It's 3 hours max from Newcastle, 2.5 from Middlesbrough. No great hardship to get up and on the road by 6.30, especially at a weekend. They wouldn't stay overnight if it was their own money and they wouldn't pay 100 quid either.
- NUFFSAID
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 656
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 5:09 pm
- Location: Manchester/Walney (Ian Gomersall)
- Contact:
Re: game off
A short term answer maybe ? - we move the pitch 2 yards away from the popular side and nearer the stand , it would mean moving the goals a couple of yards though (but small beer IMO) would this help?.
Forgot about all this new stadium tosh and swapping the pitch around - this is now and we need a solution.................puts crash helmet on in anticipation of 'are you mad' responses
Forgot about all this new stadium tosh and swapping the pitch around - this is now and we need a solution.................puts crash helmet on in anticipation of 'are you mad' responses
-
Richard Ingham
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 5125
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 3:07 pm
- Location: Chorley
- Contact:
Re: game off
As it was an area of the pitch well away from the touchline that they were working on, it would have no impact whatsoever Nuffsaid.
- NUFFSAID
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 656
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 5:09 pm
- Location: Manchester/Walney (Ian Gomersall)
- Contact:
Re: game off
cheers .....my thought for the day lol.Richard Ingham wrote:As it was an area of the pitch well away from the touchline that they were working on, it would have no impact whatsoever Nuffsaid.
- Steelworks End
- BarrowAFC Veteran
- Posts: 5959
- Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 6:03 pm
- Location: Twickenham
- Contact:
Re: game off
Assuming that Barrow anticipated that an early pitch inspection would be neccessary - and in the circumstances this would be wise - then could this not have been done by a local referee rather than the match officials?jim wrote:If the officials really were from north east and stayed overnight that is ridiculous. It's 3 hours max from Newcastle, 2.5 from Middlesbrough. No great hardship to get up and on the road by 6.30, especially at a weekend. They wouldn't stay overnight if it was their own money and they wouldn't pay 100 quid either.
I accept that the final say lies with the match referee but in these days of modern technology he should be able to liaise with the local man by phone or video, and either accept his opinion or decide that he needs to come and look for himself. If there was no chance that the game could go ahead, then the match officials would be saved a journey at 40p a mile or whatever and the visiting team & supporters would be saved a wasted journey.
This wouldn't have helped yesterday of course (assuming that the local referee decided at 9.00am that the pitch was playable) because the match official would still have called it of four hours later, but for future occasions would this not be sensible?
Whether it is the clubs that pay the match officials' expenses or the FA is not really relevant. The clubs fund the FA, the fans fund the clubs, so in the end the expenses come out of our pockets.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Esso Blue and 19 guests