Not so much the relegation that's led to the need for a clear-out, so much as a failed experiment. We bought a lot of players who were deemed to have "potential", but they never realised that potential & we now have a squad that is simultaneously both weak and bloated. Same for a lot of youth players that we had high hopes for - of which one went to Udinese but other than our current 3rd choice keeper and a defender that I mention later in this post, they've all pretty much drifted off the face of the earth.Suffolk Blue wrote: ↑Thu Aug 01, 2024 11:15 amThanks Terrier. That is a useful and comprehensive analysis. And I think we agree that he fits the profile of what we need pretty well. We've also taken young Eccleston on loan for the season. Dont know if you've come across him? The Terriers seem to be a rich source of incoming talent for us this season. I take it that the recent relegation has led to a serious clear out at the JS Stadium?Terrier78 wrote: ↑Thu Aug 01, 2024 11:04 am
Quite possibly.
I mentioned in my post above that we need to trim the squad - and we have a few strikers here that aren't quite good enough for where we want to be, but would probably do a job at Lg2 more than comfortably.
Kieran Phillips is currently on loan in the USA and looks like a cheat code over there (although the standard really is dreadful!), but he'll be back in November. Did ok at Walsall, and apparently did well at Morecambe before his injury. Would be looking for a new club because he's not going to make it here.
Kyle Hudlin, 6'9", was a punt from non-league that didn't really pay off. Didn't exactly pull up any trees on loan at Burton last season & hasn't really been involved in pre-season. Looks ungainly, surprisingly poor in the air, but quick, can hold the ball up well & a decent enough finish on him.
Kian Harratt - I'd hope he was only on loan. Great movement, great finisher, physically strong, but horribly inconsistent and has a few off-field issues (just finished a ban for betting on football matches, was caught hare coursing a couple of years ago). Has the talent to play at Championship level, but there are a few aspects of his upbringing in the travelling community that mean his adjustment to (for want of a better word) "normal" life has had a few blips.
(we also have other strikers we could do to get shut of, but I think they'll either retire with us or go back abroad)
I can't tell you a lot about Eccleston, because I've not seen him play. He only broke into the first team squad at the end of last season, and when I say that I mean literally the end. As in, he was a surprise inclusion on the bench for the last game of the season, and he was an unused sub! Apparently he's done well in pre-season though, so I'd be interested to see how he gets on with you.
Although if I'm honest, I'm also a little concerned, because... you also have Connor Mahoney who I expect will be playing in front of him on the RHS. If you want to read a positive review of Mahoney then you might be better off asking Gillingham fans, because you won't get one from me! The only performance I can really comment on from Mahoney, he was in front of a youth player that was just breaking into the first team, and he absolutely hung the kid out to dry. Left him exposed time and time again and made him look like he was horribly out of his depth, when he really just needed support. As it happens, that kid (Brodie Spencer) was loaned out to Motherwell for the first half of last season & it was the absolute making of him. Came back in January & looked every inch a top end Championship player (we'll struggle to keep hold of him this summer). But there were plenty who thought he'd never make it as a pro (at any level) after getting so consistently rinsed down his side - in that game in particular.
Other than that, Mahoney was anonymous in all the other games too - although in fairness to him he was only brought on towards the end of them. 5 or 10 minutes of anonymity is excusable. I'm told (and I've seen video footage to back it up even though he was awful for us) that he's technically excellent, so he might do ok for you. Fingers crossed.
From what I understand, Neo is better going forward than the defensive side of his game, so you will need somebody solid defensively backing him up whether Connor pulls his finger out of his arse or not.
It looks as though Mahoney did a lot better at Gillingham, so he may be OK. But I do fear for Neo Eccleston if he's left as exposed as Brodie Spencer was.